Sunlit cream stucco storefronts and a shaded bench along a tidy Florida downtown sidewalk.

New Port Richey Picked the Biggest Plan for Main and Bank. Among the Finalists, It Asks the City for the Smallest Share.

The building at 5640 Main St. has three stories and 14,397 square feet. It has no onsite parking and no doors or windows facing the street. It went up in 1957 as the Pasco County Health Department and has been empty since the county moved out in June 2021. The city acquired it on March 22, 2022, by trading the city-owned baseball fields at Pine Hill Park to Pasco County. The city's own redevelopment solicitation calls the building severely neglected and deteriorated.

On Oct. 26, the Community Redevelopment Agency, whose board is the City Council, ranked Main Street Reserve as its first choice for the site. Tampa Bay Beacons reported the decision on Nov. 2. Main Street Reserve was the most expensive of the four remaining proposals, and it asked the city to pay the smallest share of its own cost. That ratio explains the vote better than anything in the renderings.

What would go on the corner of Main and Bank

Main Street Reserve LLC, led by founder and CEO Corey Penza, proposed a new multistory building for hospitality, dining and events. The plan includes:

  • Hearth & Cellar, a 160-seat ground-floor restaurant designed with brick-and-stone arches
  • The Grand Hall, a second-floor conference and events venue for meetings and banquets
  • An upscale rooftop lounge
  • A city-owned smart parking garage with 285 spaces, 7,500 square feet of ground-floor retail and a solar panel canopy on the roof
  • A possible skywalk in a second phase, connecting the garage to the main building

The proposal also leaves room for retail, office and residential space. The total estimated cost is $22.4 million, and the CRA contribution requested is just over $3.9 million.

The funding math behind the ranking

At the Oct. 6 CRA meeting, five groups each gave a 10-minute pitch to a packed room at City Hall. Tampa Bay Beacons noted that many people in the room came to support a family destination. Comparing each proposal's request to its total cost shows how differently the five were built.

Proposal Estimated cost CRA contribution requested Share paid by the CRA Final ranking
Main Street Reserve $22.4 million about $3.9 million about 17% 1st
Sterett Holdings, The Cotee $7.65 million $4.55 million, including the building's value about 59% 2nd
Brainstorms Science Discovery Center $8.9 million $7.2 million about 81% 3rd
Museum of Archaeology, Paleontology & Science $1.15 million $750,000 about 65% 4th
Quamitry Labs, Signal House $9.26 million $1.45 million about 16% Withdrew before Oct. 26

Main Street Reserve asks the CRA for about $3.9 million, and Brainstorms asked for $7.2 million. Main Street Reserve's request would help pay for a new building, a restaurant, an events hall and a public garage. Brainstorms and MAPS each asked for a renovated building that the CRA would own and lease to them for $0 a year. The Cotee, a multilevel space for weddings, coworking, offices, hospitality suites and meetings, also proposed a community fund to support future CRA projects.

The city's stated goals for the site point the same way. It wants the project to drive economic development, raise hotel occupancy, bring more visitors to local businesses and help fill vacant buildings. A conference hall and a 160-seat restaurant serve those goals directly.

Where the science center and museum fit instead

The council didn't dismiss the family-learning proposals. On Oct. 6, Council member Bertell Butler IV backed Brainstorms. He said, "If this is truly a community redevelopment decision, if this is about what will enhance our city, then STEM-based fits that bill." Deputy Mayor Brian Jonas asked whether the former Gulf High School building would suit a science center better. He also questioned whether the Main and Bank building is structurally sound.

By Oct. 26, that view had carried the board. CRA members said the Harry Schwettman Education Center, the original Gulf High School building on Grand Boulevard, would fit Brainstorms or MAPS better because it has both indoor and outdoor space. No redevelopment is underway there yet. City Manager Debbie Manns said the city wants a plan to reuse and improve the property once environmental remediation concerns are addressed.

Brainstorms put out a statement after the vote, which the Tampa Bay Times republished. Daisy Thomas, vice president of its board, said: "We proposed it because we believe children and families belong at the center of our community's future, and downtown should reflect that." The group said it wanted the downtown site because it's close to Sims Park, the public library and local businesses. It plans to keep looking for a permanent home in New Port Richey.

What has to happen before anything is built

A first-place ranking opens negotiations. It doesn't approve a deal. Manns described these steps:

  1. City staff negotiate terms with Main Street Reserve during a due-diligence stage.
  2. If the terms hold, staff bring an economic development package and the proposed agreements to the CRA for consideration.
  3. If no agreement is reached, the CRA can go back to The Cotee, which ranked second.

Manns said the process could take up to 120 days. Counted from the Oct. 26 vote, 120 days runs to late February 2027.

The block the new building would join

Many of the businesses already on this stretch serve food and drinks, and their addresses put them right next to 5640 Main St. The city's dining directory lists Heros Downtown Subs & Salads and Main Street Deli at 5649 Main St., Melt'd and Ottaway's Ice Cream Parlor at 5641 Main St., The Social NPR at 5650 Main St., and Sasha's on the Park at 5621 Main St. Sasha's is the restaurant inside the Hacienda Hotel. The hotel's website lists 40 guest rooms and says Sasha's serves breakfast, lunch and dinner. A few blocks away, the directory lists Cotee River Brewing at 5760 Main St. and Curtain Call Coffee Bar at 5738 Missouri Ave. Richey Suncoast Theatre filmed at Curtain Call for its November 2026 newsletter.

With 40 hotel rooms a short walk from a proposed conference hall, the city's hotel-occupancy goal starts to look concrete. The garage covers the other half of the plan, because parking is already a problem downtown.

Why a 285-space garage matters here

In August, Tampa Bay Beacons reported that more downtown activity had brought parking trouble with it. Police Chief Robert Kochen told City Council on Aug. 4, "we are faced with increasing problems in the downtown area with parking and throughout the city." Council approved the first reading of an updated parking ordinance. It would raise the fine for a Class I violation from $10 to $30, and more serious violations could carry $250 fines.

Downtown parking today is spread out. The city's parking page lists free public lots at 5838 Nebraska Ave., 6538 Bank St. and 5645 Nebraska Ave., plus the New Port Richey Parking Garage at 6218 US Hwy 19. The DART trolley connects them. Main Street Reserve's 285 spaces would be the first structured parking in the historic core itself, and the city would own them.

The back of the building faces the next Railroad Square phase

Phase I of Railroad Square, the renovated pedestrian stretch of Nebraska Avenue, had a soft opening on March 20. Phase II would continue it along Nebraska Avenue from Grand Boulevard to Bank Street. The city's solicitation notes that the rear of the Main and Bank building faces that planned phase, and it asks any redevelopment to connect both Main Street and Railroad Square.

The city's proposed 2027–2031 capital improvement plan, dated Sept. 29, 2026, describes Phase II as landscaped walkways, seating, shade structures, pedestrian lighting, golf cart parking, public art and water main upgrades. The plan budgets $1.65 million in FY 2026–27, paid with tax increment funding, and $2.25 million in later years. Engineering is scheduled for 2026–2029 and construction for 2027–2029. The same plan includes a Railroad Square restroom building, with $75,000 for engineering and $500,000 for construction.

Phase II's total of $3.9 million is almost exactly what Main Street Reserve wants from the CRA. Either amount would rebuild about one block of Nebraska Avenue. Spent on the Main and Bank site, it would anchor a building whose total cost is more than five times that.

Downtown dates over the next few weeks

Several events on the holiday calendar take place within a few blocks of the site:

  • Nov. 20–22: The last weekend of Noises Off at Richey Suncoast Theatre, 6237 Grand Blvd. Evening shows are at 7 p.m. on Nov. 20 and 21, with a 2 p.m. matinee on Nov. 22. Reserved seats are $30.
  • Nov. 21: Homegrown, a free Zac Brown tribute concert in Sims Park, 5 to 8 p.m.
  • Nov. 27: The Fourth Friday Bazaar on Railroad Square, 6 to 10 p.m.
  • Dec. 4: The tree-lighting ceremony, 6 to 9 p.m., as listed by New Port Richey Main Street.
  • Dec. 5: The Cotee River Christmas Boat Parade at 6 p.m. Boat registration closes Dec. 2 and costs $25 for residents and $100 for commercial entries.

The Main and Bank building will still be standing for all of these events, empty, with no street-facing door. If talks go well, the CRA would see the full Main Street Reserve agreement and economic development package early next year.

If you own a home within walking distance of Main Street and want to see how your property compares this winter, Diaz Group can put together a free home valuation and marketing plan for you.

experience seamless buying & selling

We bring together a mix of integrity, imagination and an inexhaustible work ethic, striving to make each buying and selling experience the best possible. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Follow Me on Instagram